Bruno Jouhier (2013-07-15T23:12:47.000Z)
There is no need to CPS transform functions and there is no need for
deferred functions either. It can all be done with today's generators and a
little helper library.

With the C# async/await notation:

   - The yield keyword is your "await" keyword.
   - The little * in function* is your "async" keyword.

With this you can write:

function* asyncEach(array, fn) {
  for (var i = 0; i < array.length; i++) yield fn(array[i], i);
}

and you can call it as:

function* myFunc(array) {
  yield asyncEach(array, function*(elt, i) {
    var foo = yield asyncBar(elt);
    // more ...
  })
}

Note that there is *no* helper API in all these async functions that call
other async functions; The helper API is only needed to interface this with
the classical callback world: at the very bottom of the stack when you call
low level callbacks-based I/O functions, and at the top of the stack when
the event loop runs one of your generator functions.

The trick is that you need a clever run function to do the little
yield/next dance with generator functions that call other generator
functions.

I've implemented this in
https://github.com/bjouhier/galaxy/blob/master/lib/galaxy.js (the run and
invoke functions)

The only thing I don't like about it is the awkward syntax:

   - yield precedence does not work well
   - yield is prefix, which does not chain well
   - and yield is heavy anyway

In short, this is a hack to get going but I'm still waiting for the full
concurrency proposal and its awesome ! syntax.

Bruno

> Consider the following:
>
>       function* yieldEach(array){
>         array.forEach(n => {
>           yield n;
>         });
>       }
>
> In order for this to work, not only does `yieldEach` have to be suspended
for the inner yield, but forEach does as well. That means CPS transforming
functions based on whether they call a yielding function.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://mail.mozilla.org/pipermail/es-discuss/attachments/20130716/51738c5f/attachment.html>
domenic at domenicdenicola.com (2013-07-19T15:35:21.150Z)
There is no need to CPS transform functions and there is no need for
deferred functions either. It can all be done with today's generators and a
little helper library.

With the C# async/await notation:

   - The yield keyword is your "await" keyword.
   - The little * in function* is your "async" keyword.

With this you can write:

```js
function* asyncEach(array, fn) {
  for (var i = 0; i < array.length; i++) yield fn(array[i], i);
}
```

and you can call it as:

```js
function* myFunc(array) {
  yield asyncEach(array, function*(elt, i) {
    var foo = yield asyncBar(elt);
    // more ...
  })
}
```

Note that there is *no* helper API in all these async functions that call
other async functions; The helper API is only needed to interface this with
the classical callback world: at the very bottom of the stack when you call
low level callbacks-based I/O functions, and at the top of the stack when
the event loop runs one of your generator functions.

The trick is that you need a clever run function to do the little
yield/next dance with generator functions that call other generator
functions.

I've implemented this in https://github.com/bjouhier/galaxy/blob/master/lib/galaxy.js (the run and invoke functions)

The only thing I don't like about it is the awkward syntax:

   - yield precedence does not work well
   - yield is prefix, which does not chain well
   - and yield is heavy anyway

In short, this is a hack to get going but I'm still waiting for the full
concurrency proposal and its awesome ! syntax.